Entertainment
BBC hit with complaints over ‘heartbreaking’ Panorama documentary on cow abuse that left viewers ‘shocked to the core’
Viewers were disgusted by the horrific treatment of cows at the farm (Picture: BBC)
The BBC has been hit with complaints over a Panorama documentary which investigated farmworkers abusing cows with appalling footage.
The show, titled A Cow’s Life: The True Cost of Milk, involved a Panorama investigation into the dairy industry to explore whether animal welfare is being compromised to keep milk prices low.
Harrowing undercover footage of farmworkers abusing cows was included in the documentary, featuring cows being kicked while down, one was hit with a shovel in her face, and another being inhumanely dragged by a tractor while half suspended in the air.
The episode uncovered the brutal treatment of cows on one farm in Carmarthenshire, Wales, secretly filmed by an international animal protection organisation Animal Equality.
The farm, Madox Farm, homes more than 650 cows and their calves.
A Cow’s Life: The True Cost of Milk also highlighted issues around cow lameness and the removal of dairy calves from their mothers after birth.
The documentary was filmed in 2021, when the farm under question was supplying milk to Freshways, the UK’s largest independent dairy processor which distributes to businesses including Costa Coffee and British Airways.
Freshways has since suspended its contract with Madox Farm.
At the time the Panorama documentary aired, the controversial video sparked outrage for the abuse of the herd.
The documentary aired on 14 February (Picture: Ella Millward)
Viewers were left ‘horrified’ at the harrowing footage (Picture: Ella Millward)
International animal protection organisation Animal Equality shot undercover footage for the documentary (Picture: BBC)
Many viewers shared their disgust at the scenes on social media, with one Twitter user writing: ‘5 minutes into Panorama A Cow’s Life and I’m already horrified by the scenes.’
Another added the footage makes them ‘feel sick’, with a third writing: ‘Heartbreaking scenes of the treatment of cows in the dairy industry.’
It’s something that makes me feel sick despite being a vet student and knowing about the farming industry. How many months did it take to get this footage? I honestly believe these are isolated events that would make most dairy farmers feel sick also.
— Hattie (@Hattie230899) February 14, 2022
The BBC released a statement summarising the complaints from viewers ‘who felt the investigation misrepresented the dairy industry and failed to reflect the views of farmers.’
Many viewers recognized that this treatment was an ‘isolated incident’ based on one farm in South Wales, however, animal rights campaigners were quick to share that other cows are treated in this way for human benefit, with many people advocating for veganism and an end to dairy farming.
Many farmers are calling this an isolated incident (Picture: Ella Millward)
Madox Farm homes more than 650 cows and their calves (Picture: BBC)
Farmers have also shown outrage, claiming that their industry reputation has been tarnished by one example of horrific treatment.
One farmer spoke to Mail Online about the documentary, saying: ‘So disappointed by the BBC they have shown the vile actions of those workers on dairy farms shown.
‘But yet they won’t show the 99 per cent other dairy farms in UK producing quality milk with the best animal welfare in the world please everyone don’t think that’s the norm.’
According to Animal Equality, the documentary does more than expose one isolated incident, as its website states ‘Over the past 11 years, Animal Equality UK has investigated 43 farms and slaughterhouses, finding prolonged animal suffering, deliberate abuse or neglect, or illegality taking place every single time.’
In light of the complaints, the BBC has stated that it took ‘a number of steps to report with due impartiality,’ including ‘ input from a representative from the National Farmers Union’ and an interview with ‘a vet with extensive experience of working with dairy herds, to put the undercover filming into context within the wider dairy industry.’
More: BBC
The organisation concluded: ‘We feel the programme was duly accurate and fairly portrayed the issues involved, bearing in mind the specific editorial focus on this occasion.’
Panorama: A Cow’s Life: The True Cost of Milk is available to watch on BBC iPlayer.
Got a story?
If you’ve got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we’d love to hear from you.
